LAVCA | The Association for Private Capital Investment in Latin America
  • About
    • About LAVCA
    • Board, Team, & Advisors
    • Media
    • Contact
  • Members
    • Membership Benefits
    • Current Members
    • Member Access
  • Education & Programs
    • About
    • LAVCA Week
    • Calendar & Past Programs
    • LAVCA Education
  • Research & Directories
    • LAVCA Research
    • Industry data
    • LP Survey
    • Directories
  • ESG & Impact
    • Deal Book
    • LAVCA ESG Deal Awards
    • Impact Report
    • ESG Guidelines
  • Articles
    • Featured Articles
    • Industry News
  • VC
  • Member Login
  • Member Access

LAVCA | The Association for Private Capital Investment in Latin America

A non-profit member organization

  • About
    • About LAVCA
    • Board, Team, & Advisors
    • Media
    • Contact
  • Members
    • Membership Benefits
    • Current Members
    • Member Access
  • Education & Programs
    • About
    • LAVCA Week
    • Calendar & Past Programs
    • LAVCA Education
  • Research & Directories
    • LAVCA Research
    • Industry data
    • LP Survey
    • Directories
  • ESG & Impact
    • Deal Book
    • LAVCA ESG Deal Awards
    • Impact Report
    • ESG Guidelines
  • Articles
    • Featured Articles
    • Industry News
  • VC

Latin American Entrepreneurs: To “Flip” into a C-Corp or a LLC?

January 25, 2012
By: Juan Pablo, Principal Shareholder, Greenberg Traurig; co-founder idea.me & Sauber Energy

An emerging trend in Latin America is the significant number of Latin regional venture businesses that are using a Delaware company as a holding company for their Latin based operating group.  Sometimes these are de novo holding companies and sometime these are “Delaware Flip” transactions-where a local holding company is replaced or merged (“flipped”) into a Delaware company.

There are a number of reasons why it makes sense to put a Delaware holding company at the head of Latin based operations.   The main reason is that the U.S. remains the most active venture financing market in the world for technology companies.  Although some American venture funds are willing to invest in foreign startups, a large number of U.S. venture funds prefer to invest into a U.S. holding company.  And since Latin technology companies are almost by definition multi-country plays, they require a holding company.  Thus, the U.S. (usually Delaware) becomes a natural choice.

An issue that comes up frequently is whether initially that U.S. holding company should be a C-Corp (an “Inc.”, equivalent to an “S.A.” in Latin America) or some other type of corporate entity, perhaps a Limited Liability Company (an “LLC”, a bit similar to a “Limitada” in Latin America).

Conventional wisdom is that a company that aspires to be venture backed needs to be a C-Corp.  I agree that a C-Corp is the way to go for an U.S. based company with U.S. founders that is raising money from U.S. VC funds.   U.S. funds and institutional investors generally resist investing into an LLC because LLCs give “K-1″/pass through income which funds want to avoid.

However, before incorporating a C-Corp as a holding company, a Latin entrepreneur must keep in mind that many Latin technology companies (i) initially aren’t going to be “engaged in a U.S. trade or business”, (ii) will have a significant percentage of non-U.S. owners/investors and (iii) will likely not receive initial seed round of financing from U.S. VC funds.

While many Latin entrepreneurs expect to raise money in the future from U.S. VC funds, many Latin entrepreneurs might find (as several of my LatAm entrepreneurs clients have found recently):

(i)   they end up raising their Series A capital from a wealthy Latin family or Latin based funds,

(ii) they end up selling the company faster than they expected (without bringing in a U.S. fund), or

(iii) once their business gets going they decide they don’t need a U.S. based holding company to raise funds and they decide to move the holding company to Spain, Luxembourg or Holland (which have better tax treaties with Latin American countries) before their institutional capital raise.

Latin American entrepreneurs that flip into a C-Corp at an early stage will face:

(i)     double U.S. taxation–that is, worldwide earnings will be subject to U.S. corporate income and U.S. dividend withholding tax,

(ii)  in many cases the inability to relocate the holding company outside of the U.S. without triggering U.S. tax, and

(iii) the C-Corp will pay U.S. tax on the income of its non U.S. subsidiaries (in certain cases these taxes may be credited against the C Corp’s U.S. corporate tax liability).

Often an LLC holding company can be viewed as a free option.  A company can usually go from an LLC to a C-Corp without triggering U.S. tax.  Such a conversion requires some straight-forward paperwork and the holding company retains its taxpayer ID number so it maintains the same bank account.  On the other hand, the conversion from a C-Corp to a LLC is treated as a de facto sale, and thus is a taxable transaction in the U.S.

To summarize, the tax benefits/considerations of an LLC for a non U.S. based business are:

(i) The LLC won’t be subject to U.S. federal or state income tax (in most states) on its earnings derived from the non-U.S. subsidiaries because the LLC is not a taxpayer in itself.

(ii) The Non-U.S. Members won’t be subject to individual U.S. federal or state income tax return filing requirements on their earnings derived from the LLC, so long as the LLC is not engaged in a U.S. trade or business and the LLC does not earn U.S. source income

(iii)  The U.S. Members will get to deduct their pro rata of the losses the LLC generates in the first few years (until the LLC is profitable) against their current U.S. (often passive) income.

(iv) The U.S. members should in many cases be able to obtain favorable U.S. long-term capital gains rates on their sale of the LLC interests.

(v) The LLC holding company can sell the downstream entities (the Latin American subsidiaries) without any U.S. tax to the non-U.S. members. And the LLC holding company can relocate outside of the U.S. in the future without the relocation being treated as a “sale”.

These tax benefits are why Brazil considers U.S. LLC’s tax haven type entities (“privileged tax regime” in the words of the Brazilian tax authorities).

An LLC will have to adhere to certain reporting requirements which create some administrative borders.  The LLC will be subject to U.S. reporting requirements on an annual basis,   consisting of: (a) a Form 1065 reporting the LLC’s income, gain, losses, deductions   and credits and allocating such items among its members; (b) an FBAR with respect   to its non U.S. financial accounts, as well as the non-U.S. financial accounts of   certain of its subsidiaries if certain conditions are met; (c) disclosure forms with   respect to ownership of non-U.S. companies, such as Form 5471 for the non-U.S.  subsidiaries down the chain of ownership; and (d) an annual filing with the   Delaware Department of Corporations and payment of $250 annual tax.  In some cases, the use of the LLC may cause the underlying non-U.S. corporations to be “controlled foreign corporation,” which could have adverse affects on the U.S. members.  This usually can be avoided with proper planning.

Also the Non-U.S. members/owners of the LLC will be required to obtain a U.S. tax identification number for purposes of allowing the LLC to fulfill its U.S. tax reporting obligations.  If the members do not wish to apply for a U.S. tax identification number, they could consider using a non-U.S. corporation to hold their interest in the LLC so the non-U.S. corporation applies for such U.S. tax identification number instead of them individually.

In short, using LLCs always raises some static in venture companies.  While C-Corps work well for U.S. based venture companies, the considerations are very different when non U.S. based operations and non U.S. founders are involved.  Before “flipping” into an U.S. C-Corp, Latin entrepreneurs should at least consider the advantages of using an LLC.

Juan Pablo is a Principal Shareholder in the Latin American Group of Greenberg Traurig, an international 2,000 lawyer law firm.  Juan Pablo was the general counsel and a director of Patagon.com, which was sold to Banco Santander for a transaction value of over US$750 million.


Juan Pablo is also a well known entrepreneur and deeply involved in supporting venture capital in Latin America. He co-founded (i) www.idea.me, the first Latin America crowdfunding site and (ii) Sauber Energy, a green energy company in Chile that resolves the problem of “harmonics” in the electrical grid, while remaining a serial “seed investor” supporting many projects including Senzari (an international music site like Pandora only better), Urbita (a regional travel site), and LinkedStore (an Argentina site that supports SMEs).

He also serves on the advisory board of the Pino Entrepreneurship Center at Florida International University, as well as the advisory board of the Institute of Global International Effectiveness at the Kelly School of Management, Indiana University.

Latin American Entrepreneurs: To “Flip” into a C-Corp or a LLC? was last modified: January 25th, 2012 by Editor
1
Facebook Twitter Google +

Sign up for LAVCA’s bi-weekly Latin American Private Capital Update and the LatAm Venture Bulletin, produced specifically for venture investors, entrepreneurs, and technology startups in the early stage ecosystem.






Which LAVCA Newsletter would you like to receive?

VC Partner Events

    Tweets

    • We are excited to welcome a new member to our team, Marcelo A. Pizzato Dantas, Director of Programs and Partnership… https://t.co/5HEv1k8pWC

      24-May-2022

      Reply Retweet Favorite
    • Private capital funds deployed a total of USD5.5b across 215 transactions in Q1 2022, representing an 88% increase… https://t.co/U2ljIBGrFp

      20-May-2022

      Reply Retweet Favorite
    • #LAVCAData for Q1 2022 recorded a total investment of USD2.8b across 190 transactions in Latin America. Compared to… https://t.co/AZRsVwOcbn

      19-May-2022

      Reply Retweet Favorite
    • LAVCA's Associate Director of Research Emanuel Hernandez and Executive Director @naitafur explain trends in regiona… https://t.co/jMIUJfa6KZ

      16-May-2022

      Reply Retweet Favorite
    • Today's top takeaways from the #LatAmVentureBulletin: https://t.co/TdVT3WZ6YT

      12-May-2022

      Reply Retweet Favorite

    Submit VC News

    Have private equity or venture capital related news that you would like to share? Submit your press releases and news to [email protected].

    VC Industry News

    • Vinci Partners Acquires USD20m Stake in Brazilian Credit Provider DMCard

      February 21, 2022
    • 8VC Leads ~USD35.4m Round for Brazilian Insurtech 180 Seguros (em português)

      February 2, 2022
    • Glade Brook Capital Leads USD125m Series C for Chilean Insurtech Betterfly

      February 2, 2022
    • SP Ventures and Acre.VC Lead USD10m Series A for Brazilian Carbon Trading Marketplace Moss (em português)

      January 31, 2022
    • Brazilian Healthtech Nilo Saúde Raises USD10m Series A from Canary, MAYA, SoftBank, GFC and Tau Ventures

      January 28, 2022
    • Valor Capital Group Leads ~USD16m Series A for Brazilian Agtech Agrolend (em português)

      January 23, 2022
    • DILA Capital and Kayyak Ventures Lead USD15m Series A for Mexican Financing Platform Fairplay

      January 18, 2022
    • Astella Investimentos Leads ~USD4.6m Seed Round for Brazilian Blockchain Trading Platform Gavea (em português)

      January 12, 2022
    • SoftBank Leads USD48m Series B for Colombian E-commerce Laika

      January 12, 2022
    • KASZEK Leads USD13.2m Round for Mexican Fantasy Sports Platform Draftea

      January 7, 2022
    • IDC Ventures Leads ~USD5m Series A for Brazilian Microcredit Platform SuperSim (em português)

      January 6, 2022
    • Mexican Verification Platform MetaMap Raises USD70m Series B

      January 5, 2022
    • DRADS Capital Leads USD7m Pre-Series A for Chilean Foodtech The Live Green Co. (en español)

      January 3, 2022
    • SoftBank Leads USD127m Round for Brazilian Healthcare Provider Alice

      December 21, 2021
    • DILA Capital and ALIVE Ventures Lead USD14m Series A for Edtech Slang

      December 20, 2021
    • Astella Investimentos and SoftBank Lead ~USD3m Seed Round for Brazilian Automation Platform BotCity (em português)

      December 20, 2021
    • GIC Leads USD80m Round for Colombian POS Lending Platform ADDI (em português)

      December 20, 2021
    • Yara Growth Ventures Leads USD30m Series C for Argentine Agtech Agrofy (em português)

      December 16, 2021
    • Tiger Global Leads USD60m Series B for Mexican Freight Platform Nowports

      December 16, 2021
    • SoftBank Leads ~USD120m Round for Brazilian Fintech OpenCo (em português)

      December 15, 2021
    • DN Capital Leads ~USD22.2m Series A+ for Brazilian Healthtech Sami

      December 14, 2021
    • Riverwood Capital Leads ~USD52m Series B for Brazilian Fiscal Management Platform Arquivei (em português)

      December 14, 2021
    • KASZEK Leads USD2.7m Seed Round for Peruvian Edtech Crack the Code

      December 13, 2021
    • GIC Leads ~USD32m Series C for Brazilian Delivery Platform Shopper (em português)

      December 13, 2021
    • Tiger Global Leads USD20.5m Round for Mexican Freight Platform Nuvocargo

      December 10, 2021
    • Advent International and SoftBank Lead USD60m Series B+ in E-Commerce Aggregator Merama

      December 9, 2021
    • Volpe Capital Leads ~USD5m Series A for Brazilian Corporate Governance Platform Atlas Governance

      December 8, 2021
    • Lachy Groom Leads USD14.8m Series A for Brazilian Fintech Stark Bank (em português)

      December 8, 2021
    • Prosus Ventures Leads USD60m Series B for Colombian Edtech Platzi

      December 6, 2021
    • KASZEK Leads USD10m Series A for Brazilian Workspace Marketplace Beer or Coffee (em português)

      November 30, 2021
    • Galapagos Capital Invests ~USD20m in Brazilian Cosmetics MedBeauty (em português)

      November 18, 2021
    • Oak HC Leads USD27m Series A for Mexican Payment Platform Aplazo

      November 15, 2021
    • Colombian E-commerce Fulfillment Platform Melonn Raises USD4.5 Seed Round

      November 3, 2021
    • DNA Capital, Temasek and Fit Participações Lead ~USD20m Round for Brazilian Healthtech Memed

      November 1, 2021
    • Astella Investimentos Leads ~USD5m Round for Brazilian Proptech Homelend (em português)

      October 28, 2021
    • KASZEK Leads USD8m Round for Brazilian Car Documentation Platform Gringo

      October 27, 2021
    • SoftBank Leads USD75m Series C for Brazilian BPO Platform Pipefy

      October 26, 2021
    • Mexican Delivery Platform Skydropx Raised USD20m Seres A from Cometa, Base10 Partners, 645 Ventures

      October 26, 2021
    • Brazilian Car Insurtech Justos Raises ~USD35.8m Series A from SoftBank, KASZEK and Others

      October 25, 2021
    • Andreessen Horowitz and Base Partners Lead USD15m Series A for Colombian Foodtech Foodology

      October 22, 2021
    • Unbox Capital Leads USD30m Series B for Brazilian Marketing Platform Rock Content (em português)

      October 22, 2021
    • L Catterton Leads Investment in Mexican DTC Eyewear Brand Ben & Frank

      October 21, 2021
    • Anthos Capital Leads USD18m Series A for Venezuelan Delivery Platform Yummy

      October 21, 2021
    • Flourish Ventures and GFC Lead USD10m Series A for Brazilian Wholesale Marketplace Merce do Bairro

      October 21, 2021
    • Tiger Global Leads USD35m Series A for Argentine Fintech Pomelo

      October 21, 2021
    • Brazilian Wholesale Marketplace Inventa Raises ~USD6m Seed Round (em português)

      October 20, 2021
    • QED Investors and KASZEK Lead USD40m Series C for Brazilian Fintech Hash

      October 20, 2021
    • SoftBank, Amazon and Accel Lead USD108m Series B for Brazilian Fintech Pismo (en español)

      October 19, 2021
    • SP Ventures and Astella Investimentos Lead USD17m Series A for Brazilian Fintech Traive (em português)

      October 18, 2021
    • Tencent and SoftBank Lead USD200m Series F for Brazilian Trucking Marketplace CargoX (em português)

      October 15, 2021
    • Valor Capital Group Leads USD22m Series A for Mexican Edtech Aprende Institute

      October 11, 2021
    • Square Capital and Hard Yaka Invest USD15m in Colombian Digital Payments Platform Movii (en español)

      October 6, 2021
    • Atlantico Leads USD6m Series A for Brazilian Wholesale Marketplace ZAX

      October 5, 2021

    About LAVCA

     

    LAVCA is the Association for Private Capital Investment in Latin America, a not-for-profit membership organization dedicated to supporting the growth of private capital in Latin America and the Caribbean through research, education, networking and advocacy.

    LAVCA Office

        New York City:
        589 8th Ave, 18th Floor
        New York, NY 10018

    Explore LAVCA.org

    • About LAVCA
    • Board, Team, & Advisors
    • Media
    • Contact Us
    • Membership Benefits
    • Members Only Access
    • Education and Programs
    • Research
    • Policy
    • LAVCA VC
    • Contact Us

    @2020 - LAVCA. All Rights Reserved.


    Back To Top